Skip to main content
Visionnment Estimate value
Menu

Business Growth

How to Choose Three Competitors for an SEO Audit

Choose three SEO competitors that serve the same buyer, service and market. Try a five-candidate Phoenix example and copy the selection worksheet.

Visionnment guide to choose SEO competitors, with a three-step search, compare, choose diagram.

Choose competitors a buyer could actually switch between. A business that is easy to find in Google can be useful research without belonging in your shortlist. Start with five candidates, record where each appeared and use three practical filters to select the strongest comparisons.

Write down the job you are competing for

Write the buyer, service, location and one deal-breaking requirement. A Phoenix commercial cleaning company might define its target as a facility manager hiring recurring after-hours office cleaning in the metro area. The owner budgets and staffs that work differently from one-off household cleaning. They may also need a separate comparison for clinics if they can meet the distinct service requirements.

Start with “office janitorial service Phoenix” and “medical office cleaning Phoenix.” Record each search separately and log the result type, exact page URL and date. Keep the area from which you searched in the record. The aim is to find businesses the buyer might evaluate. A snapshot is less useful for tracking rank than it is for seeing whether a page and offer answer the buyer’s problem that day.

Filter five candidates to three

Use a short decision for every candidate:

  1. Same buyer. Could a person with the buyer’s decision authority request the service there? The site should speak to the relevant purchaser and say which properties, teams or accounts it serves.
  2. Same service. Find the page that explains the work. A general services list is weaker evidence than a page that describes an area of overlap and gives the buyer a practical next step.
  3. Same market. Check the business’s public service area and any scope limitations. Look for a credible way the provider could serve the buyer’s location.

Count a competitor once. If it appears as an ad and an organic result, keep both observations for that single business. Keep directories, marketplaces and industry lists in a separate research list. The company behind a directory may not submit a bid for the job, but competitors found on that directory could still apply.

Worked shortage and shortlist example

The following example demonstrates how to classify five candidates. It does not present today’s list of Google results. ServiceMaster Clean’s Phoenix janitorial page and BullsEye’s commercial cleaning page offer service-specific material to inspect. Verify support for the actual buyer and work before selecting either.

Candidate Direct buyer and service? Market evidence Decision
ServiceMaster Clean Phoenix janitorial page Published janitorial services Phoenix service page Shortlist if the recurring office scope fits
BullsEye commercial cleaning Published commercial cleaning Phoenix-area business evidence Shortlist if the recurring office scope fits
A verified local building-services provider, illustrative Offers recurring office cleaning to property teams Publishes service for selected areas in the metro Shortlist after confirming the overlap
Directory with office-cleaning listings, illustrative Connects buyers with providers Lists businesses in the market Keep as a research source
Residential deep-cleaning business, illustrative Speaks to household buyers about occasional visits Convenient location Keep outside the shortlist for recurring office work

If you end up with only two credible local choices, consider a neighboring service area and note the change. Give the third-slot candidate a qualified label. For example, a provider can be an informative comparison if its offer closely matches yours but its geography overlaps in only part of the market. Narrowing the job first often improves the list more than expanding the search radius.

Copy the competitor selection worksheet

Business and exact page Search, date, area and result type Evidence the buyer fits Evidence the service fits Evidence the market fits Use / qualify / exclude

Fill the last column before considering how well the page is written. A compelling presentation is worth studying after you know the company competes for the job. If the owner sells both offices and clinics, make a second shortlist for clinic work. Keep the two lists and write down when the same business belongs on both.

Choose one public page from each shortlist business. Record the admission decision once and link back to it when you compare offers and enquiry paths. That saves a future reviewer from guessing why a large brand, a directory or a specialty company appears in the worksheet.

For the full workflow, return to the DIY competitor SEO audit. If you want help testing where three candidates overlap with your offer, bring their URLs and the buyer and market you wrote down to the competitor visibility report.

Apply this method to your industry

  • Employer vs. Candidate Search Intent for Staffing Agency SEO
  • Should Your SaaS Build a Competitor Comparison Page or a Category Landing Page?
  • How to Tell Whether Your Medical Billing Website Attracts Practice Owners or Patients